Type of Publication: | Journal article |
Publication status: | Published |
URI (citable link): | http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:352-0-405443 |
Author: | Bech, Kristin; Walkden, George |
Year of publication: | 2016 |
Published in: | Nordic Journal of Linguistics ; 39 (2016), 1. - pp. 65-100. - ISSN 0332-5865. - eISSN 1502-4717 |
DOI (citable link): | https://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0332586515000219 |
Summary: |
In their recent book, English: The Language of the Vikings, Joseph Embley Emonds and Jan Terje Faarlund attempt to make the case that from its Middle period onwards, English is a North Germanic language, descended from the Norse varieties spoken in Medieval England, rather than a West Germanic language, as traditionally assumed. In this review article we critique Emonds & Faarlund's proposal, focusing particularly on the syntactic evidence that forms the basis of their argumentation. A closer look at a number of constructions for which the authors suggest a Norse origin reveals that the situation is not as they present it: in many cases, the syntactic properties of Old and Middle English are not given careful enough consideration, and/or the chronology of the developments is not compatible with a Norse origin. Moreover, the authors do not engage with the large body of sound changes that constitute the strongest evidence for a West Germanic origin. We conclude that Emonds & Faarlund fail to make a convincing case either for a North Germanic origin or against a West Germanic origin.
|
Subject (DDC): | 400 Philology, Linguistics |
Keywords: | Anglicized Norse, language classification, language contact, Middle English, Old English, syntactic change |
Link to License: | In Copyright |
xmlui.ArtifactBrowser.ItemViewer.detail.textAllianzLicense | |
BECH, Kristin, George WALKDEN, 2016. English is (still) a West Germanic language. In: Nordic Journal of Linguistics. 39(1), pp. 65-100. ISSN 0332-5865. eISSN 1502-4717. Available under: doi: 10.1017/S0332586515000219
@article{Bech2016-05Engli-38536, title={English is (still) a West Germanic language}, year={2016}, doi={10.1017/S0332586515000219}, number={1}, volume={39}, issn={0332-5865}, journal={Nordic Journal of Linguistics}, pages={65--100}, author={Bech, Kristin and Walkden, George} }
Bech_0-405443.pdf | 542 |