(Non-)factive (non-)islands and meaning-based approaches

Cite This

Files in this item

Files Size Format View

There are no files associated with this item.

DJÄRV, Kajsa, Maribel ROMERO, 2022. (Non-)factive (non-)islands and meaning-based approaches. SALT 31 : the 31st Semantics and Linguistic Theory Conference. Providence, RI, May 7, 2021 - May 9, 2021. In: DREIER, Nicole, ed. and others. Proceedings of SALT 31. Ithaca, NY:Department of Linguistics, Cornell University, pp. 184-200. eISSN 2163-5951. Available under: doi: 10.3765/salt.v31i0.5134

@inproceedings{Djarv2022Nonfa-57526, title={(Non-)factive (non-)islands and meaning-based approaches}, year={2022}, doi={10.3765/salt.v31i0.5134}, address={Ithaca, NY}, publisher={Department of Linguistics, Cornell University}, booktitle={Proceedings of SALT 31}, pages={184--200}, editor={Dreier, Nicole}, author={Djärv, Kajsa and Romero, Maribel} }

2022 Djärv, Kajsa 2022-05-12T13:35:22Z Romero, Maribel 2022-05-12T13:35:22Z eng Djärv, Kajsa terms-of-use A key question in the literature on factive Weak Islands has been whether the effect is syntactic or semantic. Since Szabolcsi & Zwarts (1993), a key argument for the semantic nature of Weak Islands is the observation that the effect requires not just factivity, but also that the property described by the embedded clause is non-iterable with respect to the extracted argument (uniqueness). We present two caveats concerning the notion of factivity needed in meaning-based approaches. First, we present novel data on factive non-islands showing that certain lexically factive verbs do not (always) lead to islandhood when combined with uniqueness. Second, recalling data from Cattell (1978), we argue that certain non-factive islands can be captured by the same meaning-based explanation. The emerging picture is that lexical factivity of the embedding verb is neither necessary nor sufficient to induce weak islands in combination with uniqueness; rather, what matters is whether or not there is a contextual entailment, pragmatic or lexical, that the complement proposition is true. (Non-)factive (non-)islands and meaning-based approaches Romero, Maribel

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Search KOPS


My Account