KOPS - Das Institutionelle Repositorium der Universität Konstanz

Measuring success of constitutional reforms : evidence from territorial reforms in eight western democracies

Hinweis

Eine neuere Fassung von diesem Dokument befindet sich zur Zeit im Geschäftsgang.

Measuring success of constitutional reforms : evidence from territorial reforms in eight western democracies

Zitieren

Dateien zu dieser Ressource

Prüfsumme: MD5:348391a6b0ae5bc49e7dab38156ad24d

BEHNKE, Nathalie, Bettina PETERSOHN, Andrea FISCHER-HOTZEL, Dominic HEINZ, 2011. Measuring success of constitutional reforms : evidence from territorial reforms in eight western democracies. In: Regional & Federal Studies. 21(4-5), pp. 447-477. ISSN 1359-7566. eISSN 1743-9434

@article{Behnke2011Measu-19071, title={Measuring success of constitutional reforms : evidence from territorial reforms in eight western democracies}, year={2011}, doi={10.1080/13597566.2011.578935}, number={4-5}, volume={21}, issn={1359-7566}, journal={Regional & Federal Studies}, pages={447--477}, author={Behnke, Nathalie and Petersohn, Bettina and Fischer-Hotzel, Andrea and Heinz, Dominic} }

Petersohn, Bettina Studies of constitutional reforms so far have equated formal ratification with a successful reform. The paper goes beyond this narrow focus by adding substantive success as a second dimension based on two indicators: degree of agenda fulfilment and degree to which the reform contributes to solve the constitutional problem. Analysing territorial reforms in unitary or federal states, we distinguish two types of problems—group and efficiency problems. The comparative analysis of formal and substantive success demonstrates that first, reforms can be at least partly successful in terms of substance, although they may have failed formally; second, fulfilling the reform agenda seems to be a necessary but not a sufficient condition for solving the constitutional problem at stake; third, cases with group problems score higher on both indicators, thus being more successful than cases with efficiency problems. Furthermore, the characteristics of the two most successful cases suggest that opportunities for participation, open dialogue and consensus building play an important role in explaining the results. Fischer-Hotzel, Andrea 2012-06-20T07:06:28Z Publ. in: Regional & Federal Studies ; 21 (2011), 4-5. - pp. 447-477 2011 Heinz, Dominic Fischer-Hotzel, Andrea Petersohn, Bettina Measuring success of constitutional reforms : evidence from territorial reforms in eight western democracies deposit-license Behnke, Nathalie eng Behnke, Nathalie Heinz, Dominic 2012-06-20T07:06:28Z

Dateiabrufe seit 01.10.2014 (Informationen über die Zugriffsstatistik)

Behnke_190711.pdf 8

Das Dokument erscheint in:

KOPS Suche


Stöbern

Mein Benutzerkonto