Social progress at the expense of economic equality? : New data on left parties' equality preferences

Abstract

Have concerns about equal rights and equal chances crowded out economic equality as a priority of left parties? Despite the increased importance of inequality in political science, this contentiously fought debate has been standing on shaky empirical foundations. While voter's equality preferences are well understood, parties’ equality emphases remain uncharted territory. This research note assesses whether the Left has replaced its emphasis on economic equality with a focus on equal chances and equal rights. Based on a new dataset of 300,000 party statements, we use online crowd-coding to map the equality trajectories of left parties in 12 OECD countries from 1970 to 2020. We examine if trade-offs between economic and non-economic aspects of inequality have come to dominate left parties’ equality profiles. Distinguishing social democratic, green and far-left parties, we refute a meritocratic or ‘woke’ crowding out of redistribution. Yet, Social Democrats have indeed forsaken the once complementary link between economic equality and equal rights in favour of a weak trade-off.